|
Optoma HD70
|
General Impressions / Feature Set
Click Here to go to the Optoma HD70 Information Page
The HD70 has a high
gloss white case, with grey trim on the sides and rear. It is not
overly branded, with small "HD Ready" and "DLP" logos on the front and
an Optoma badge up top. In all, it has a minimalist appearance that
hides an impressive projector.
The 1.2:1 manual
zoom range is sufficient for adjusting the image to fit your screen,
but doesn't allow for a lot of placement flexibility. The HD70 will
project a 100" 16:9 image from 11.5 feet to 13.8 feet. If you sit at a
viewing distance of 1.5x the screen width (or 10.8 feet), you can put
HD70 just behind the seating area, which will help to reduce
distractions from audible noise and heat exhaust.
The HD70 has a
generous, fixed throw angle offset. The bottom edge of the projected
image will appear 33% of the image height above the centerline of the
lens. So for example, if you are projecting a 100" 16:9 image, the
bottom edge of the image will be about 16" above the lens centerline.
This makes the HD70 a good candidate for table or ceiling mounting.
Ceiling mounting gives you the most flexibility in arranging the
projector, screen, and seating just the way you want it. However, it is
more of an installation project, and the incremental cost of the
ceiling mount, video cables, and perhaps some drywall work are
additional factors to consider in this budget range.
Table placement is
easier, quicker, and less costly. Due to the throw distance, if you
place the projector on a coffee table in front of you it will mean that
you are sitting further back than 1.5x the screen width. Some users
will prefer that, and others won't. If you want to be closer to the
screen, another option is put the unit on a low table between the
seats. Rear shelf mounting above and behind the seats is also possible,
but it will require a significant forward tilt to keep the projected
image from appearing too high on the wall, and you'll need to use the
keystone correction feature to square it up. The HD70's remote
control is similar to other Optoma remotes in that it is small,
backlit, and low on clutter. Next to the Power button is a "mode"
button, to switch between Cinema, Bright, TV, sRGB, and User. There are
four buttons corresponding to the HD70's aspect ratios (4:3, 16:9,
Letterbox, and Native), as well as common image adjustments like
brightness, contrast, and overscan. In addition, there are individual
buttons for the projector's sources, as well as a button to cycle
through all of them -- a bit redundant. Finally, there are buttons to
control both horizontal and vertical keystone without going through the
menus.
The menu is
divided into four subsections, labeled Image, Display, Setup, and
Options. Image contains all the standard picture controls, like
contrast, brightness, and colour. In addition, the "advanced" menu
contains settings for BrilliantColour, TrueVivid, ImageAI, gamma
settings, independent red/green/blue settings, and colour temperature.
BrilliantColour allows for a brighter picture while maintaining colour
accuracy, and on the HD70 it manages to do so without blowing out
highlights too severely. TrueVivid actually enhances colour performance,
boosting saturation and making the picture appear more
three-dimensional. However, taking this control too far cuts down on
shadow detail, so we left this setting on 1 (out of 3) for normal
viewing.
"Display" contains
aspect ratio controls, overscan adjustment, edge masking, image shift,
and keystone correction. "Setup" and "Options" contain more
maintenance-oriented options that you will likely only have to adjust
once.
Performance
After exploring the
options, we selected the settings most ideal for dark-room home theatre
-- low lamp, Cinema mode, with BrilliantColour at 5 or 6 and TrueVivid
at 1. In this mode, our test unit measured 398 ANSI lumens. Given the
contrast of the unit, this is easily enough light to fill a 120"
diagonal 16:9 screen in a room with good light control. By changing
over to "Bright" mode and switching the lamp to high, light output was
boosted to 756 ANSI lumens. While this cuts down on contrast, it does
provide a bright, colourful image that is ideal for video games in some
ambient light. Contrast performance is solid. I personally like to watch a lot of "dark" films, such as Michael Mann's Heat and Collateral.
While viewing these two films on the HD70, shadow detail was nuanced
and easily visible. I found myself noticing details that I had
forgotten about in the two films, and I was very pleased with the
HD70's dynamic picture quality.
ImageAI is
becoming a staple of Optoma projectors, and functions to increase
on/off contrast. When enabled, lamp mode is no longer selectable, and
the projector automatically adjusts lamp power to fit the scene being
displayed. For example, a bright sunny scene might push lamp output
higher, while dark scenes will bring the lamp back down to its lowest
output.
While this does
drive on/off contrast higher, it has no effect on ANSI contrast, so any
given scene viewed on its own will look the same as it did with ImageAI
turned off. It also brings lamp life down from the maximum, and fan
noise will cycle higher and lower. So if you're looking for the best
possible performance, and you're willing to give up a few hours of lamp
life to get it, it's best to leave ImageAI on.
The HD70 has
comprehensive colour adjustment controls which we found ourselves not
needing. Our review sample was very close to 6500K out of the box, and
did not require much fine-tuning. We did notice a bit of unevenness in
solid colours with subtle differentiations in tone. For example, flesh
tones on occasion showed a clear differentiation, essentially a line,
between two very close shades of the same basic colour, instead of a
smooth gradient. This is due to the projector's 8-bit colour processing.
The more expensive home theatre projectors on the market today have
10-bit or 12-bit colour processing, so they can display more subtle
variations in colour resulting in smoother transitions from tone to
tone. However, in most instances, the effect of the 8-bit processing on
the HD70 was subtle and easy to ignore. Aside from this issue, colour
was well saturated and accurate.
De interlacing was
better than expected for such a budget projector. The HD70 was able to
de interlace 480i material from our DVD player with near-flawless
precision. We saw very few artifacts, all told. Quality was comparable
to that of one of our in-house DVD players with Faroudja DCDi
processing, and flipping between them yielded few differences.
The HD70 has a
remarkably noise-free picture. In areas that are usually "jumping" with
image noise, we saw very little to none at all. This is a definite
improvement over many other projectors, and makes for a very "clean"
viewing experience. Optoma's HD70 vs. HD72
The next step up in DLP home theatre projectors is the Optoma HD72,
a 1280x768 machine with similar specifications and a price tag around
£1400. What does the HD72 have that the HD70 does not that makes it
worth the extra money?
The primary
advantage of the HD72 is that its 1280x768 resolution display allows
you to project 1280x720 video, 1024x768 computer signals, and 1280x768
wide screen data, all in native format without scaling. The HD70 is
native 1280x720. That is fine for HD video, but data signals in XGA and
WXGA format must be compressed. If you need a projector that will serve
well for both video and data presentation, the added versatility of the
HD72's 768-line display will better suit your needs.
The HD72 and HD70
have nearly identical throw distances - the HD72 will display a 100"
diagonal image from an additional 6" away from the screen, but they are
otherwise identical. The HD72's throw angle is one or two percent lower
than the HD70, so both are best suited for either ceiling or table
mounts.
In actual home
theatre usage, lumen output on both projectors was virtually identical
despite the 300 lumen difference in ratings. When properly set up for
dark room home theatre, our HD72 measured 385 ANSI lumens while the
HD70 measured 398 ANSI. On the other hand, when calibrated for video
game use, the HD72 measures 985 ANSI lumens while the HD70 clocks in at
756. This incremental light output may be helpful in brighter ambient
light conditions or on particularly large screens. It can also be
useful in XGA and WXGA data presentation, which the HD72 is more suited
to due to its 768-line display.
Contrast
performance was about equal as well. The HD72 seems to bring out
incrementally more shadow detail and a slightly better black level, but
the difference is only really noticeable in a side by side comparison.
The HD72 shows
some slightly better colour performance. The tonal gradient issue that
we observed on the HD70 was nowhere to be seen on the HD72, primarily
due to the HD72's 10-bit colour processing versus the 8-bit processing
on the HD70. The result is smoother, less noticeable differentiations
on the HD72 than on the HD70.
High definition
content looked stellar on both projectors. However, the extra contrast
and colour smoothness of the HD72 help to give it an incrementally more
three-dimensional picture. The HD70 still displays a fine high
definition picture, but the HD72 is a bit more elegant when placed
head-to-head.
Finally, the HD72
has several other features that the HD70 lacks including both a DVI and
an HDMI port, lower audible noise, and an overall more solid-feeling
build quality. Yet the main differences are in the physical resolution
and the slightly more sophisticated image quality. If 1280x768 is
something that you need, then the HD72 is the way to go. However, the
HD70 comes reasonably close to matching the HD72 in video performance
for half the price. That is a hard bargain to beat.
Conclusion
The Optoma HD70 is
an important projector in that it brings 720p DLP under £800 for the
first time. While it does not quite rise to the level of the HD72 in
pure image quality, it delivers a bang-up image at a bargain basement
price. If you've been thinking about getting into front projection home
theatre for the first time, we would wholeheartedly recommend that you
look at the Optoma HD70. There are some fine lower resolution 480p
projectors available today for even less than the HD70. But when 720p
is available at this price, it's hard to say no.
|